The Butter House | Critical Book Review

In Sarah Gerard’s novella, The Butter House, the concept of home takes center stage, woven through a narrative that blurs the lines between human and animal experiences. Erin Britton dives into the contemplative journey, where the author delves into the essence of place, identity, and the subtle dance between external events and one’s internal world.

A Floridian Escape

The story unfolds as a young couple abandons the chaos of New York for the tranquility of Florida. Amidst the creamy yellow house and the boyfriend’s wildlife internship, Gerard crafts a narrative that gracefully dissects the couple’s attempt to redefine their lives.

Weighty Matters in a Slight Package

Despite its seemingly modest length, The Butter House grapples with substantial themes. The girlfriend’s internal monologue hints at a deeper motivation behind the move, suggesting a struggle beyond the superficialities of city life. Gerard skillfully explores the shadows of potential depression, prompting the reader to question the true reasons behind the relocation.

Lightness and Darker Realities

As the protagonist navigates her new surroundings, Gerard skillfully weaves moments of introspection. The girlfriend’s initial relief and confusion slowly unfurl, revealing a complex emotional landscape. The author delicately balances the character’s mundane tasks with subtle signs of growth and self-discovery.

A Cat Person’s Tale

The Butter House is, at its core, a cat person’s story. Gerard introduces a delightful contrast between feline adoration and wry observations about cats’ cunning nature. The novella’s charm extends beyond cat lovers, injecting humor into the narrative and broadening its appeal.

Atmosphere and Metaphorical Barriers

Gerard excels in creating a vivid atmosphere within the house and its neighborhood. The girlfriend’s perception of the residence as bright and freeing juxtaposes with her apprehensions about the unfamiliar surroundings. The metaphorical barriers she constructs hint at deeper struggles, adding layers to the story.

Charming Reflections on Domestic Life

In its brevity, The Butter House leaves a lasting impact, exploring the possibilities of building a home and family. Gerard skillfully balances thought-provoking musings with humor, offering a charming and profound perspective on the nuances of day-to-day

Publisher, Genre, Print Length, ISBN

PublisherGenrePrint LengthISBN
Conium PressLiterary Fiction70 pages9781942387190

In Sarah Gerard’s novella, The Butter House, the concept of home takes center stage, woven through a narrative that blurs the lines between human and animal experiences. Erin Britton dives into the contemplative journey, where the author delves into the essence of place, identity, and the subtle dance between external events and one’s internal world.…