Soiled Dove Murder | Critical Book Review

Soiled Dove Murder by Sherilyn Decter takes readers on a historical rollercoaster, blending history, mystery, adventure, and action in a 1920s setting. Joelene Pynnonen dives into the heart of this indie historical novel to uncover the twists and turns of Lucie Santoro’s entanglement with mobsters in Virginia City.


Lucie’s Dilemma

Schoolteacher Lucie Santoro, enjoying her summer break, unexpectedly finds herself entangled in a web of danger. The once-impecunious Ruth, Lucie’s old pupil, now manages a bordello facing a crisis. Lucie’s moral compass clashes with her duty as she delves into a perilous journey to rescue one of Ruth’s “soiled doves,” risking not only her career but her life.


The Evolution of Moonshiner Mysteries

The third installment of The Moonshiner Mysteries sees a shift in focus, with Lucie taking the lead while Delores Bailey steps into a supporting role. Decter’s choice to spotlight Lucie breathes new life into the series, revealing the stark differences between the two protagonists. Lucie’s character arc unfolds against the backdrop of 1920s societal norms, showcasing her quest for independence.


Historical Richness

Decter’s meticulous attention to historical detail shines in Soiled Dove Murder. The narrative delves into the racial discrimination, sexism, and morality of the 1920s, offering readers an immersive experience of the era’s less savory aspects. The protagonists grapple with the values of their time, presenting fully rounded and empathetic characters.


Gripping and Nuanced

Soiled Dove Murder proves to be a clever, nuanced, and entertaining read. Pynnonen commends Decter’s ability to captivate readers with a storyline that explores complex themes while maintaining a sense of fun. The novel not only engages but also challenges the characters, broadening their understanding of the world.


A Sheriff’s Absence

While showering praise, Pynnonen playfully laments the absence of Sheriff Sam Browne in this installment. Recognizing the necessity for the plot, the reviewer humorously stands by the opinion that Sheriff Browne’s presence could have added an extra layer to the narrative.


Conclusion: A Delightful Kickoff

Soiled Dove Murder emerges as a delightful kickoff to the year 2023. Pynnonen recommends it as a must-read for those seeking a solid historical adventure. With tantalizing unresolved mysteries weaving through the series, the book promises an engaging and exhilarating experience, leaving readers eagerly anticipating more.

Publisher, Genre, Print Length, and ISBN

PublisherGenrePrint LengthISBN
IndieBookViewMystery, Thriller & Suspense / Historical479 pages9781777515140

Soiled Dove Murder by Sherilyn Decter takes readers on a historical rollercoaster, blending history, mystery, adventure, and action in a 1920s setting. Joelene Pynnonen dives into the heart of this indie historical novel to uncover the twists and turns of Lucie Santoro’s entanglement with mobsters in Virginia City. Lucie’s Dilemma Schoolteacher Lucie Santoro, enjoying her…