Oversight | Critical Book Review

Oversight, penned by Dennis Batchelder, catapults readers into an exhilarating young adult adventure, a delight particularly for fans of the iconic Quantum Leap series. Let’s delve into the riveting escapade through the lens of Alexandria Ducksworth’s discerning critique.


Unveiling Past Lives: A Rollercoaster of Teen Quantum Leap

Batchelder, with finesse, navigates the intriguing terrain of past lives, offering readers a thrilling ride reminiscent of the beloved Quantum Leap saga. The narrative, with its relentless pace, hooked me from the outset, making it a challenge to tear myself away. In Oversight, Soul Identity, an entity rooted in ancient civilizations, holds the key to preserving memories for future lives, setting the stage for an enthralling exploration of destiny and deception.


Zelly’s Odyssey: A Chess Game of the Mind

The protagonist, Zelly, poised to become the next overseer, faces a perilous predicament—her potential demise at the hands of her best friend and adversary, Ying. This YA novel weaves a tale of mystery and suspense as Zelly, armed with knowledge from her past self, strives to uncover the hidden history of Soul Identity and thwart Ying’s sinister ambitions. The interplay of past lives is a standout element, sparking thought-provoking discussions on the plausibility of past-life tapping.


Intelligent Protagonists and a Chess Match of Wits

What elevates Oversight is not just its thrilling plot but the intelligence radiating from its characters. Zelly, a tech-savvy South American teen, clashes with Ying, her equally brilliant rival, in a cerebral chess match that keeps readers guessing until the final move. The novel’s portrayal of their intellectual sparring is akin to witnessing a high-stakes chess tournament between two master players.


A Sci-Fi Gem with Reflective Undertones

This YA sci-fi gem seamlessly integrates excitement, action, and cutting-edge technology, all set against a modern backdrop that makes the Metaverse seem archaic. Oversight offers a reflective exploration of past lives and reincarnation, presenting a thought-provoking canvas for young readers. History enthusiasts will relish Batchelder’s vivid depiction of Ancient Rome, adding an extra layer of richness to the narrative.


Conclusion: A Future Classic in YA Sci-Fi

In conclusion, Dennis Batchelder deserves ample kudos for crafting a captivating and intelligent YA sci-fi adventure. Oversight not only delivers on its promise of excitement but also leaves room for contemplation on themes of destiny and the echoes of the past. Here’s hoping for more from Batchelder’s imaginative world—no pun intended. Oversight stands as a testament to the enduring allure of YA science fiction, destined to be cherished by readers seeking a blend of thrills, intellect, and speculative exploration.

Book Details

PublisherGenrePrint LengthISBN
IndieBookViewYoung Adult / Science Fiction352 pages978-0979805660

Oversight, penned by Dennis Batchelder, catapults readers into an exhilarating young adult adventure, a delight particularly for fans of the iconic Quantum Leap series. Let’s delve into the riveting escapade through the lens of Alexandria Ducksworth’s discerning critique. Unveiling Past Lives: A Rollercoaster of Teen Quantum Leap Batchelder, with finesse, navigates the intriguing terrain of…