Mistletoe & Mishigas | Critical Book Review

Mistletoe & Mishigas unfolds a tale of unexpected love amidst a fake dating scenario for the holidays. Sheldon, a first-grade teacher, thrust into a new school, grapples with the stress of attending his ex’s Christmas wedding. Enter Theo, the school’s custodian, a reluctant colleague turned spontaneous date for Sheldon. The narrative delves into the dynamics of their contrasting personalities, paving the way for a potential genuine romance.


Exasperation and Grumpy-Sunshine Dynamics

M.A. Wardell crafts an opposites-attract, grumpy-sunshine romance where initial exasperation with the characters transforms into endearment. Sheldon’s overcompensating demeanor clashes with Theo’s stoic exterior, creating a tension that builds towards an anticipated transformative love. Wardell’s writing establishes a clear and impactful connection with the characters, sparking emotional engagement and anticipation.


Scorching Romance and Family Bonds

The narrative unfolds with scorching hot intimacy, bright opposites-attract chemistry, and a sweet found family dynamic. Mistletoe & Mishigas caters to readers who relish size-difference tropes, varying sexual experiences, fake-dating scenarios, and hurt-comfort narratives. The book navigates the insecurities of two men discovering love, evoking an impossibly enchanting atmosphere that captures the reader’s heart.


Size Differences and Triggering Moments

The story explores the significance of size differences in Theo and Sheldon’s relationship, occasionally teetering on treating it as unfortunate. While Sheldon’s character arc is rooted in self-discovery and acceptance, some moments may trigger readers, particularly in the treatment of Theo’s body.


Theo’s Profound Journey

The standout character, Theo, brings depth to the narrative with a poignant backstory of love, loss, and enduring grief. Flashbacks to his military romance offer a moving portrayal, showcasing Theo’s resilience in the face of trauma. His journey, coupled with genuine moments of love and patience, adds a layer of emotional richness to the story.


Realistic Humor and Disorienting Pacing

Mistletoe & Mishigas blends holiday-appropriate humor with earnest character interactions, creating a rom-com that feels more like a plausible love story. The pacing, while slightly off-kilter for regular romance readers, immerses the audience in the charm of Theo and Sheldon’s dynamic. The novel’s realistic approach momentarily overshadows the usual fantasy, offering a refreshing take on the genre.


In conclusion, M.A. Wardell’s Mistletoe & Mishigas delivers a captivating and contrasting romance, weaving together humor, intimacy, and emotional depth. While navigating through triggering moments and atypical pacing, the novel offers a genuine portrayal of love, making it a worthwhile read for those seeking a unique romantic experience.

Publisher, Genre, Print Length, and ISBN:

PublisherGenrePrint LengthISBN
IndieBookViewRomance / LGBTQ302 pages9798987787540

Mistletoe & Mishigas unfolds a tale of unexpected love amidst a fake dating scenario for the holidays. Sheldon, a first-grade teacher, thrust into a new school, grapples with the stress of attending his ex’s Christmas wedding. Enter Theo, the school’s custodian, a reluctant colleague turned spontaneous date for Sheldon. The narrative delves into the dynamics…