Five Wishes | Critical Book Review

Five Wishes by Karin M. Gertsch offers a heartwarming exploration of the interplay between ambitious dreams and comforting stability. In this indie novel, Gertsch weaves a narrative that delves into the buried dreams, compensatory aspects of love and family, and the ever-ticking clock of chasing one’s desires. While the story is a beautiful blend, it leans heavily on positivity, perhaps to the detriment of fully exploring the darker, more complex aspects of its characters’ aspirations.


Small-Town Charm and Family Dynamics

Set in the quaint town of Hamlet in New England, the narrative revolves around Bertie, the owner of the beloved Peach of a Sole shoe repair shop, and his wife Tilli, an avid gardener. The couple’s two daughters add depth to the tale, bringing a sense of nostalgia and homeliness to the plot. Tilli’s proposal of a trip reveals hidden wishes and secrets, setting the stage for a heartfelt exploration of familial bonds.


A Cozy Setting and Vivid Descriptions

Gertsch’s skillful storytelling brings the small town to life through vivid descriptions, making the setting as inviting for the reader as it is for the characters. The attention to small details paints a serene image of life in a close-knit community. This embrace of the setting allows the characters to shine, with even the mundane aspects of their lives gaining a captivating quality within the backdrop of a small town.


Positive Overtones and Missed Opportunities

While the overwhelmingly positive tone contributes to the warmth of the story, it occasionally feels like the narrative shies away from fully delving into the sadness and aspirations of the protagonists. The tendency to turn every sad event into a lesson or epiphany, while uplifting, may leave some readers yearning for a more nuanced exploration of the characters’ emotional landscapes.


Conclusion: Warmth and Enjoyment

In conclusion, Five Wishes is an enjoyable read that skillfully unfolds the tale of a family through their past, present, setting, and travels. The characters become intimately known in this story of love, loss, and learning. Despite its inclination towards relentless positivity, this warm narrative is a compelling journey that shouldn’t be overlooked.

Publisher, Genre, Print Length, and ISBN

PublisherGenrePrint LengthISBN
Atmosphere PressLiterary & General Fiction / Small Town294 pages9781639887910

Five Wishes by Karin M. Gertsch offers a heartwarming exploration of the interplay between ambitious dreams and comforting stability. In this indie novel, Gertsch weaves a narrative that delves into the buried dreams, compensatory aspects of love and family, and the ever-ticking clock of chasing one’s desires. While the story is a beautiful blend, it…